You realized that there is a need for Business Transformation in your organization. And now, you are looking for consulting services
to help you sail through the long journey you are about to take. Well, you look
out for choices in the market and there is a variety available to pick:
1. Independent Consultants - bringing breadth and
depth of industry experience
2. Small Consulting firms - talking niche skills
3. System Integrators - generally providing
technical capabilities
4. Consulting houses - helping in strategy
direction
It would be really hard to
classify any other variety outside the 4 types mentioned above. And you would
get your needs met either by mix or going with a single choice, depending on your
preference. The extended consulting provided by product/package vendors is
limited in nature and hence does not make broader differentiation to this
subject. For Business
Transformations programs, the subject goes beyond aspects of capabilities
rather principles. “TCQIV” comes into
play wherein T is for Time, C is for Cost, Q is for
Quality, I is for Impact and final one V which is for Value realized either in
tangible or intangible terms.
So, looking from outsiders view
on TCQIV based on what we have heard and seen with clients, in 20 years, for
large transformation programs, it represents an interesting picture as shown
below.

"Independent Consultant & Small Consulting companies makes client's life simple"
Well,
there are soft sides to business decisions as well which influence TCQIV principles.
After all, business decision makers are humans too and they look for
humanitarian aspects as well to make a successful transformation journey and
they could vary from organization to organization. However over the years of
experience, we have seen some of them to be looked in more critically than some
of others. And no matter what one says about choice of hiring, these aspects
have played a significant role in the making of the final decisions. At times, even
some businesses give soft aspects a higher weightage than others purely due to
the fact that business acumen and technical knowledge can be learnt however
softer aspects of organization are built over a period of time and are the foundation
pillars of success.

"Large Consulting firms and System Integrator's focus on selling their 'partner / framework' service to client"
Moreover, the risk-taking appetite
and financial stability, at times, does not favor independent and small
consulting firms. However they negate it by demonstrating high ethics,
integrity and innovation. And because they are more open to co-create with
client, financial risk or IP based revenue sharing models generally make things
easier with independent and small consulting firms.
SI (System
Integrator) and big consulting firms on the other hand seek revenue generation opportunities by
selling their services. They are biased predominantly due to the partnerships they have which at times have averted clients moving away from
co-creation opportunities with them as they result in more complex collaboration
than co-creation.
What is the right strategy to hire?
Business transformation needs a
mature decision and budget distribution across phases of the program.
Experience has shown that it is best to have an ‘unbiased’ view for strategy,
vision, roadmap and vendor evaluation followed by a collaborated model with an
SI for execution phases. Independent consultants generally do not carry any
partnership representations and hence are more unbiased as compared to others
however they should bring in industry leadership in their approach. Independent consultants and small
consulting firms are more flexible and innovative and can think beyond the box and can help in defining strategies. SI and large consulting firms have partnership tags and hence
they influence decisions for strategy, software evaluation and vendor selections. Their biggest strength is in execution.
Though how much one tries to make
a business transformation look simpler, it is always full of perplex and
complex situations which are unique to client business and hence no single
entity is the right solution. Right mix of talents and partners is the
direction one should take to make a business transformation journey successful.